Coming from Verizon… AT&T absolutely and thoroughly sucks. I gave up my Treo 700w on network that totally rocked from Florida to upper Michigan and everywhere in between except in areas where there is more livestock than telephone poles.

And those AT&T commercials need to be more like:
– More dropped calls in more places
– 3G is typically where you’re not – hell we’re still looking for it ourselves.
– We’re hiring some geeky guy in black rim glasses to go find it for us.
– AT&T Scavenger Hunt – If you can find 4 or more bars on 3G call us we’ll give you one meeelion dollars

Flash is must!!! Just a simple use-case – I’m totally into the Olympics and I Googled ‘medal counts’ on my iPhone tonight. Over half of the 10 hits had some kind of Flash on it – NOT on the iPhone! I never realized how many sites had Flash on them until I got an iPhone. It’s a great Flash detector. I sure would like to see Flash on the iPhone.

And one that isn’t on your list that is incredibly annoying… no cut & paste. Maybe Job’s is waiting for someone to develop it in the App Store? Who knows!

Summary – great hardware, innovative UI, horrible network. To save my marriage, I’m keeping the phone(s) (wife can’t do without the flashlight app and I’ve got to have that iPint app ). But if I could move it to an EVDO network, I’d be there in a New York minute. Sorry, Jeff Burton.